Issue 146  |  9 June 2010

Having trouble viewing this newsletter? Try the online version.

From the Director

Happy Matariki everyone!

I had the privilege of attending an addictions studies course at AUT on cessation a few weeks ago. It was a privilege because it was taught by Dr Hayden McRobbie.

Hayden made New Zealand's cessation solutions seem so clear and do-able. He had such hope and confidence about how we could reach smokers with ABC (Ask, provide Brief advice, refer to Cessation treatment)) and inspire them to make a difference for themselves and their families – it was infectious.

It all made me get a bit mathematical. Hayden showed the class a model for calculating quit success. I spent a lunch hour punching numbers into the model to see just how far a successful ABC outcome could go for New Zealand.

The current situation looks like this: for every 100 smokers in New Zealand maybe 44 make a quit attempt each year. Thirty-three of those will try cold turkey – 75 percent – and we know about 2-3 percent of these will succeed. The remaining 11 will try a treatment or a quit service or both. These have a higher rate of success – perhaps 15 percent – but because there's so few of them, we still only see another one or two people actually succeeding out of that initial 100.

So in a population of 650,000 smokers – and remember 80 percent say they wish they could quit – even 20,000 successful quits is a push, while a fresh cohort of youth take up smoking in roughly the same numbers, leaving little chance of lowering the national prevalence rate.

But once ABC is rolling up and down our country, we might finally start to see dents in more of our graphs.

What if 80 out of every 100 smokers made a quit attempt every year, and 60 percent of them – 48 – tried our services and treatments? What if our greater coordination and follow up with these ex-smokers upped our quit success rate to 20 or even 25 percent? The number of successful ex-smokers might jump as high as 80,000 in the first year! At that rate, there's a real possibility of significantly reducing the prevalence rate in New Zealand by 2020, through effective cessation practices (along with other measures).

Then when you add greater incentives to quit provided by higher taxation, and less incentive to start smoking or relapse by removing tobacco products from retail display, well! No wonder Hayden McRobbie never stops smiling! The vision just keeps getting clearer.

Take care,

Prudence Stone, Director,
Smokefree Coalition

IN THIS ISSUE:

World Smokefree Day: Protecting our Whare Tangata

The focus of World Smokefree Day is to protect women from the harm of tobacco marketing and smoking.

Hon Tariana Turia wants to draw attention to the responsibility of all New Zealanders to consider others around them before they pick up a cigarette.

"Tangata whenua have often drawn on the symbolism of te whare tangata – to describe the vital role that women play in nurturing future generations. It is timely then to remember the fundamental link between the health and wellbeing of our mothers and their children."

"The World Health Organization (WHO) theme lends itself to us thinking about the damage caused from second-hand smoke, which places women and their unborn babies at risk; and also the harm caused to children who live in homes where there are adult smokers."

Maternal smoking during pregnancy increases the risk of premature delivery, perinatal mortality, low birth-weight and may cause a reduction in breast milk.

"I am particularly mindful of the high smoking prevalence amongst Māori women; a factor which has been highlighted during the current inquiry by the Māori Affairs Select Committee into tobacco issues," said Mrs Turia.

"Tupeka Kore Aotearoa 2020/Tobacco Free New Zealand 2020 suggests that eradicating smoking from New Zealand is the single most important and attainable policy action to reduce inequalities in mortality for Māori and Pacific peoples."

Mrs Turia also referred to a study published in the New Zealand Medical Journal which identified at least eight mechanisms used to market tobacco to New Zealand women.

"Advertisements brand certain cigarettes as being 'light', playing on appeals to concerns around weight or health' or package them in a way which is designed to attract a female audience.

"The WHO theme on targeting the marketing strategies of the tobacco industry, alerts us to the ways in which advertisements may falsely link tobacco use with female beauty, including perpetuating a myth that smoking is a good way of keeping slim."

The Associate Health Minister noted that the consultation process seeking feedback on a proposal to have all tobacco displays and products stored out of public view had closed on 21 May, and she looks forward to receiving the results from that consultation.

"We must do everything we can to help people quit smoking and to stop young people from being tempted to take it up," said Mrs Turia.

"We know that if we must work on all fronts to achieve the vision laid out by the Smokefree Coalition 'that future generations of New Zealanders will be free from exposure to tobacco products and will enjoy tobacco free lives'."

Hon Tariana Turia media release, 31 May 2010

Record numbers quitting as World Smokefree Day heralds a new era

Smokers are quitting and supporting each other to quit in record numbers, according to new figures. One month on from the tobacco tax increase, and at the time of World Smokefree Day (31 May), health experts are predicting we're a few years from a smokefree New Zealand.

Quitline, which spoke to more people in one day than ever before when the tobacco tax increase was announced, reports that people are quitting by the thousands:

  • around 2100 people have called each week since the tax increase – double the pre-tax average
  • several thousand others have requested $3 nicotine patches through Quitline's website
  • this last month saw 1700 people sign up to Quitline's blogging community, where smokers share their quitting stories and support each other.

Paula Snowden, Chief Executive of The Quit Group which runs the Quitline, said World Smokefree Day comes during one of the most historic times in New Zealand's tobacco control history.

"The tax increases have provided the trigger many people seem to have been waiting for – prompting thousands to quit. Meanwhile, the Māori Affairs Select Committee is calling the tobacco industry to account, a move long overdue. It's initiatives like this which are making a smokefree Aotearoa an increasing reality.

"The record number of people using our blogs to help each other to quit, and stay quit, is extremely encouraging. Often the best support a smoker can receive is from someone else who has quit – whether that's one of our advisors or someone in the online community."

Ms Snowden said if someone has tried quitting but relapsed, they are always welcome to come back to the Quitline.

"The more attempts you make the more chance you will succeed.

"Smoking is misleadingly and deliberately portrayed as a personal choice, a statement of freedom. But the sad irony is its very nature is to remove choice and rob people of their freedom, replacing it with an addiction that kills one in every two smokers."

Quit Group media release, 28 May 2010

Nurses promote World Smokefree Day

The New Zealand Nurses Organisation (NZNO) celebrated World Smokefree Day – a global event that draws attention to the effects of smoking, on Monday 31 May.

NZNO Kaiwhakahaere, Kerri Nuku is a member of Smokefree Nurses Aotearoa New Zealand (SNANZ) and is NZNO's spokesperson for Smokefree Coalition Tupeka Kore Campaign. She is clear about the need for stronger action to increase quit rates.

"As health professionals, we deal first-hand with the consequences of tobacco use every day. We see its effects on our patients' physical and mental health, and the social, economic and cultural wellbeing of their whānau," she says.

"We are well aware of the highly addictive nature of tobacco, that it causes more deaths in New Zealand than any other drug, and that it is responsible for the death of 5,000 New Zealanders each year, (4700 smokers and 300 from second-hand smoke), of which 600 are Māori.

"I am proud to say that NZNO strongly advocates for legislation and strategies that help smokers quit and to prevent our rangatahi from starting to smoke in the first place. At the moment we are asking Government to eliminate tobacco retail displays in Aotearoa New Zealand.

"Surveys show that tobacco displays in dairies, petrol stations, supermarkets and convenience stores make it more difficult for smokers to quit or stay quit and international evidence also shows that marketing tobacco to younger people influences their uptake of smoking. We must remove tobacco products from sight in retail outlets to protect children and young people from uptake, addiction and all the terrible health outcomes that follow.

"Eradicating smoking is the single most important and attainable thing we can do to reduce inequalities in mortality for Māori and Pacific peoples and NZNO members are committed to supporting patients to quit and stay quit," Kerri Nuku said.

New Zealand Nurses Organisation media release, 28 may 2010

New ASH website feature: 'Research of the month'

Action on Smoking and Health NZ (ASH) has added a 'Research of the month' to its website. The first entry featured research demonstrating that the UK 'No Smoking Day' campaign is incredibly good value for money.

'No Smoking Day' has featured regularly on the UK calendar since 1984. ASH NZ piloted 'No Smoking Day' in Whangarei in 2005 and it has since become an annual event across Tai Tokerau/Northland.

The entry includes a link to the research abstract in full.

ASH is keen to hear your suggestions for future 'Research of the month' pieces. You can read 'Research of the month' at the ASH website, and send in your suggestions here.

Registrations for the PHA Conference 2010 are now open

You can now register for the PHA's 2010 Conference "Tomorrow for Tomorrow's People", to be held 22-24 September at Turangawaewae Marae in Ngaruawahia.

The programme is available at http://nzphaconference.info/assets/2010-PHA-conference-programme.pdf.

From researching racism to achieving health equity, to the impact of the recession on health inequalities; from internet smoking cessation in the Bay of Plenty to the question of whether water rights are a public good or private resource; from attaining childhood immunisation targets to doing better with the "health cheque"; from a Māori model of non-violent parenting to spirituality as a public health issue – the topics are wide-ranging; thought provoking and inspiring.

Earlybird registration (until 9 July) will save you $70 so get to it! Mark it in your diary, book your flights or car ride and register for the "must attend" public health event of 2010.

Go to http://nzphaconference.info/registration. If you are not a PHA member you can save even more money by joining! See www.pha.org.nz/membership.html.

Invercargill World Smokefree Day Walk

Celebrating World Smokefree Day by walking in Invercargill on 31 May were staff and friends of Awarua Social and Health Services. The group of 80 people walked from South City, Invercargill, to the Murihiku Marae. Leading the group along Tramway Road are flag bearers Crystal Ellis (left), a Youth Tutor at Frontline, and Brittany Niania.

Whānau Ora worker Frances Maheno said the walk was traditionally held most years to celebrate World Smokefree Day. The service also received several inquiries from Māori wanting to give up smoking, she said.

Southland Times, 1 June 2010

New Zealand women targeted by tobacco companies

Despite the passing of the Smoke-free Environments Act in 1990 restricting advertising and sponsorship of tobacco, tobacco companies are still targeting women with their marketing, according to a team of researchers from the University of Otago, Wellington and a Māori health research group – Whakauae Research for Māori Health and Development.

The new research, published in the latest New Zealand Medical Journal, shows there are at least eight ways in which tobacco companies get round the spirit of the law and 'push' tobacco specifically at women. The study was released to coincide with 'World Smokefree Day' on Monday 31 May, which has a theme this year of tobacco marketing to women.

"We have analysed a relatively unknown area; the marketing of tobacco to women in New Zealand, and particularly Māori women, 50 percent of whom still smoke," says Dr Heather Gifford from Whakauae.

"Smoking is more serious for women than men before middle age because it has negative health impacts on children; perinatal mortality, low birth weight and premature birth are just some of these effects", she says.

"There's also the known impact of second-hand smoke on such conditions as asthma and sudden infant death syndrome."

The study shows there are at least eight ways that tobacco companies continue to try to persuade women to take up or continue smoking despite the current law.

  • Female oriented cigarette brand names such as Cameo Mild, Vogue Bleue and Topaz are displayed in shops.
  • Fashion magazines imported into New Zealand still have cigarette advertising directed at women with women smoking – including brands available in New Zealand.
  • Using a variety of female-orientated packaging design and colours along with use of extra slim cigarettes such as Vogue Bleue, and Dunhill Essence.
  • Continuing use of deceptive terms such as 'light' and 'mild' in online advertising, counter to a ruling by the Commerce Commission in 2008. Also the use of words like 'subtle' and 'mellow' to describe former 'light' brands. Female smokers are more likely to use 'light' brands and this may delay quitting by providing what the consumer believes are less harmful alternatives.
  • The availability of menthol cigarettes as women are more likely to smoke menthols. Menthol smokers are often under the misperception that these cigarettes are less harmful to health.
  • Women have lower average incomes, and are attracted to lower priced tobacco, price discounting and roll-your-owns.

The researchers concluded that the advertising and sponsorship restrictions in the current law are inadequate and need to be expanded. One of their recommendations is to follow the lead of Australia and regulate plain packaging of all tobacco products.

"Given the ongoing examination of tobacco issues by the Māori Affairs Select Committee, now is an excellent time to further advance new laws for tobacco control," said Dr Gifford.

"We argue for a full phase out of tobacco sales over 10 years – but improved marketing controls would be a valuable supplementary measure."

University of Otago, Wellington, media release, 27 May 2010

Submitters' impressions about the inquiry

We asked members who presented orally to the Māori Affairs Select Committee inquiry to tell us their impressions in just a few sentences each.

Janet Hoek, Professor of Marketing,
University of Otago

1. Tell us how you really think you did?
I think the presentation went OK. Most committee members seemed receptive.

2. Is there anything you forgot to say?
Paul Quinn has questioned the success of smokefree initiatives and I wish I'd had more information about campaign evaluations that I could have used to respond to this comment. I also found it difficult to respond to graphs he had in front of him, but that I couldn't see!

3. What was your favourite part of the experience?
Hone nodding in agreement throughout my presentation!

4. What do you think the Select Committee still needs to hear?
Some members (a minority) still need to be convinced that past smokefree initiatives have been successful. For them, success is a steady and apparently quite rapid decline in prevalence. Some don't understand how difficult this is to achieve, particularly in environments that are still redolent with tobacco imagery and cues.

5. Are there still gaps for future presenters to fill? Can you make suggestions for the last hearing's presenters?
Keep providing evidence about what past campaigns have achieved and keep exposing industry practices, and how these undermine smokefree work.

Recent research

Click the links below each piece for more information.

Cigarette smoking and depression: tests of causal linkages using a longitudinal birth cohort

This study sought to examine the causal relationships between smoking and depression via fixed-effects regression and structural equation modelling.

http://bjp.rcpsych.org/cgi/content/abstract/196/6/440

Menthol heightens exposure to carcinogens in tobacco

Menthol is a flavoured tobacco additive claimed to mask the bitter taste and reduce the harshness of cigarette smoke. The objective of this study was to determine whether menthol influenced the penetration of the TC nitrosonornicotine across porcine buccal and floor of mouth mucosa.

http://ntr.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/ntq084

Smoking-based selection and influence in gender-segregated friendship networks: a social network analysis of adolescent smoking

The main goal of this study was to examine differences between adolescent male and female friendship networks regarding smoking-based selection and influence processes using newly developed social network analysis methods that allow the current state of continuously changing friendship networks to act as a dynamic constraint for changes in smoking behaviour, while allowing current smoking behaviour to be simultaneously a dynamic constraint for changes in friendship networks.

http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/123390827/abstract

Smoking cessation quitlines: an under-recognised intervention success story

This article summarises the development, content, structure, empirical status, and current reach of cessation quitlines. We note the rich research opportunities afforded by quitlines, describe some recent approaches to improving their effectiveness, and suggest that an understanding of how quitlines work could also improve their effectiveness.

http://psycnet.apa.org/index.cfm?fa=browsePA.volumes&jcode=amp

Risk reduction before surgery – the role of the primary care provider in preoperative smoking and alcohol cessation

This was an exploratory prospective trial. The outcome measured was the number of patients referred to a preoperative smoking and alcohol cessation programme at the same time as being referred for elective surgery by their GP.

http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6963/10/121

Tobacco use patterns in traditional and shared parenting families: a gender perspective

As part of a longitudinal, grounded-theory study with 28 couples to examine the place of tobacco in the lives of new parents, each parent participated in one or two individual, semi-structured interviews during the first three years postpartum. Grounded theory methods and a gender relations framework were used to analyse transcribed data.

http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/10/239

SMOKEFREE SHORTS

Where possible, links to full articles are provided below each story.

New Zealand

Henare fumes over tobacco giant's stance

Māori Affairs Select Committee Chairman Tau Henare has condemned the refusal of tobacco giant Philip Morris to give evidence to his Select Committee and has threatened to invoke a little-used parliamentary power against it.

The tobacco company's refusal to give evidence to the Select Committee, which is investigating the impact of smoking on Māori, showed a lack of respect for Parliament, Henare told the Sunday Star-Times.

"They're playing silly buggers," he said. "This has got nothing to do with the fact that they're the naughty boys [in the smoking debate]."

Sunday Star Times, 6 June 2010

Canterbury Mental Health Services fully smokefree

From Thursday 1 July 2010, Canterbury District Health Board's (CDHB's) Specialist Mental Health Services, including all inpatient and outpatient units, will become completely smokefree.

This is being done to ensure these services are safe and healthy for everyone, including staff, consumers and visitors. It also brings these services in line with the CDHB's smokefree policy.

Scoop, 27 May 2010

Ban on smoking upsets patients

Psychiatric patients are being treated worse than criminals under a new smoking ban at mental health service sites, some Canterbury patients say.

A Christchurch woman, who asked to remain anonymous, said people in mental hospitals had fewer rights than prisoners.

The Press, 28 May 2010

Zoo joins tidal wave of bans on smoking

Auckland Zoo has banned smoking from Saturday 29 May, riding the growing wave of opposition to lighting up at outdoor venues.

Smoking is banned by law indoors at all workplaces and everywhere – both indoors and outdoors – at schools and early childhood centres.

Now a growing number of outdoor venues, universities and polytechnics are choosing to ban smoking. Nearly a third of city and district councils actively discourage smoking in their playgrounds and sports fields, mainly by putting up signs.

New Zealand Herald, 27 May 2010

Bay band out of Smokefree after musician's sneaky puff

A band competing at the competition's regional heat at Mount Sports Centre over the weekend was disqualified after one of its musicians was caught smoking.

Smokefree Rockquest coordinator Glenn Common told the Bay of Plenty Times organisers had no choice when a band member was snapped smoking at the front of the venue.

Bay of Plenty Times, 1 June 2010

United Taxis develops smokefree policy

Dunedin taxi company United Taxis has recently developed a smokefree policy whereby their premises and taxis are smokefree at all times.

The policy was designed by the company to benefit both customers and staff, and its implementation has already motivated a number of smokers within the company to take steps towards quitting.

The company says the ban has been received surprising well by its drivers, about 40 percent of whom smoke. Some drivers have been motivated to quit by the new rule.

Story includes video.

Channel 9, 1 June 2010

International

FDA tobacco chief to industry: 'Long way to go'

The head of the [US] government's tobacco regulator says the Food and Drug Administration's new power to regulate tobacco is a promising tool to reduce the toll of disease and death caused by tobacco use.

Associated Press, 24 May 2010

Mental health smoking ban

Northern Tasmania's primary mental health ward is banning smoking on its grounds in a bid to stop patients smoking to cope with stress and anxiety.

Northside at the Launceston General Hospital will instead provide in-patients with nicotine replacement therapy.

ABC, 25 May 2010

South Australia bags 'Dirty Ashtray Award' for second consecutive year

South Australia has the dubious distinction of receiving the Australian Medical Association's (AMA's) annual Dirty Ashtray Award for the second year in a row for the Australian State or Territory that made the least progress on combating smoking during 2009/10.

Ahead of World No Tobacco Day on 31 May, AMA Federal President, Dr Andrew Pesce announced results of the AMA/Australian Council on Smoking and Health National Tobacco Scoreboard.

The scoreboard allocates points to each state and territory in various categories, including legislation, to track how effective governments have been at combating smoking in the previous 12 months.

MedIndia, 28 May 2010

Half of smokers fail to quit alone: poll

About half of smokers said they have tried stopping once without help from professional treatment but failed, an online survey showed.

The survey, jointly conducted by China's Ministry of Health and the Life Times newspaper ahead of World No Tobacco Day, polled 15,559 Internet users in the country.

China.Org, 1 June 2010

Smoking workers clock up a week off each year

Workers who take smoking breaks may be clocking up as much as eight days' extra leave every year, a conference in Dublin has been told.

Miriam Gunning, Acting Senior Health Promotion Officer on Tobacco in the Health Service Executive (HSE), said she was given the estimate by a human resource officer from outside the sector.

The Independent, 28 May 2010

American cigarettes contain more carcinogens

Cigarette-smoking Americans receive higher doses of the most potent carcinogens than do smokers in many foreign countries because of variations in the way tobacco is processed for cigarettes, researchers from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report.

Kentucky.Com, 1 June 2010

Virus links women smokers to cancer risk

Scientists believe they have discovered why women smokers are twice as likely to develop cervical cancer than non-smokers.

They found nicotine works with a certain molecule to increase the cancer-causing effect of the sexually-transmitted infection Human Papilloma Virus (HPV).

HPV causes around 70 percent of cervical cancers, which kill 1000 UK women each year.

And though up to 80 percent of women will be infected with HPV at some point in their lives, it usually needs no treatment and is harmless.

The Mirror (UK), 12 May 2010

Ireland risks slipping back to pre-smoking ban levels

Ireland is in danger of slipping back to pre-smoking ban levels because of the Government's failure to implement a comprehensive anti-smoking strategy, warns the Irish Heart Foundation.

The Irish Examiner, 1 June 2010

UK duty-free cigarette ban on the cards

Cigarettes will disappear from Britain's duty free shops after a period of being sold from "behind closed doors" as the Government tightens anti-smoking laws.

Mark Riches, Chief Executive of World Duty Free, Britain's biggest airport shopping chain, expects to set up closed-off areas for cigarette sales from 2013, in which the brands won't be on display. The company aims to replace its most profitable product ahead of an expected total ban.

The Telegraph, 31 May 2010

Smoking a turn-off: survey

Smokers be warned: You're not as attractive as your non-smoking counterparts. A new survey suggests even smokers themselves prefer dating partners who don't light up.

The West Australian, 30 May 2010

Public smoking bans effective for youth

Children and teens who live in counties banning smoking in public places have much lower levels of a second-hand smoke biomarker, US researchers found.

Study leader Melanie Dove, who received her doctorate in Environmental Health at Harvard School of Public Health this year, said the team examined data from the 1999-2006 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, a cross-sectional survey designed to monitor the health of the US population.

UPI.Com, 7 June 2010

Smoking, lack of exercise impacts sexual and urinary function

Healthy lifestyle choices – such as exercising regularly and not smoking – can significantly impact sexual and urinary function, according to new data was presented at the 105th Annual Meeting of the American Urological Association.

Medical News Today, 2 June 2010

QUOTABLE QUOTES

"This is an opportunity for me to serve my country by preventing its men, women and children from suffering and dying from tobacco-related diseases."

Dr Lawrence Deyton, Director of the FDA's Center for Tobacco Products tells a Tobacco Merchants Association annual meeting in Williamsburg, Virginia that his job is to address the enormous toll of confusion, suffering and death caused by tobacco use in the US.
"FDA tobacco chief to industry: 'Long way to go'", Associated Press, 24 May 2010

"If New Zealand was the only country that banned tobacco, it would be kind of cool."

Tau Henare, "Henare fumes over tobacco giant's stance",
Sunday Star Times, 6 June 2010

 

Subscription info

The Tobacco Control Update is produced by the Smokefree Coalition
PO Box 12-084, Wellington | P: +64 4 472 0157 | E: director@sfc.org.nz | W: www.sfc.org.nz
If you have received this email newsletter in error or wish to unsubscribe click here.
Past issues archive